DEROSA, East Deschire -- Conservative Sen. Denna Halitz has lost a hand recount in her Senate primary race.
East Deschire Secretary of State Jenny Sinderman today certified the results of the recount, which was conducted at the request of Halitz, after she lost an earlier machine recount to challenger Nancy Lindselli.
The final tally from the hand recount - which will be the official vote tally - has Lindselli winning with 50.44% or 186,991, and Halitz ending with 49.56% or 183,714.
Sinderman certified the results today, and reiterated her confidence in the outcome of the hand recount.
"I'm confident the final count from the hand recount is accurate," said Sinderman.
The hand recount was requested by Halitz, who initially was declared the winner a week after primary election day, drawing 50.5% to Nancy Lindselli's 49.5%.
After the original count, Lindselli, a former senator, requested and paid for a machine recount, which found her to be the winner, by a margin of 50.3% to 49.7%.
A desperate Halitz then requested - and also paid for - a more in-depth hand recount, which is considered a more accurate method of counting than a machine.
Last week, Lindselli was found to be the winner of the hand recount, having gained a small amount of votes.
Denna Halitz spent the last week considering her options - either concede and accept defeat, or launch an uphill Independent campaign for the Senate.
Today, the incumbent, who is seeking a second term, announced she will run as an Independent in the fall general election.
"Now is not the time for surrender. I have a vision for this state, for this country, and I intend to show the people of East Deschire over the next three months why they should send me back to the Senate, and why my opponent's partisanship and divisive ideological warfare is not right for East Deschire," said Halitz, referring to Lindselli's hard-hitting political style.
During her news conference, Halitz did not mention her NAT opponent, Assemblywoman Donna Rae Cobb (who represents the Hansboro-based seat of Forkwich), by name.
"East Deschireans deserve to have a choice in this election, and the choices couldn't be more clear. On the one side, we have a radical, bitter partisan, whose only goal is to go to Mavocke and give fiery speeches, trash-talk President Menuhaeo and oppose every bill from the Nationalists out of spite.
"On the other side, we have the exact opposite. We have someone who will rubber stamp everything President Menuhaeo and the Nationalists propose," said Halitz, referring to Cobb.
"And now I'm giving the voters a third choice. A proven conservative who loves East Deschire and will vote for what's right for East Deschire. I won't be an automatic 'no' vote and I won't be an automatic 'yes' vote. I won't obstruct the president, but I won't rubber stamp everything he wants either. I will vote for what's right for this state. I will oppose President Menuhaeo when he's wrong, and I'll back him up when he's right. But I won't demonize him and call him names and vote no just to be a thorn in his side. That's not the type behavior we need in a senator. We need someone who's compassionate, thoughtful, objective, professional, respectful to their colleagues, open-minded, and someone who's willing to partner with the other side if it means getting things done," said Halitz.
She continued: "I am here today to announce that I will continue my campaign for the Senate as an Independent. I accept the results of the multiple vote counts, and I accept that I have lost the nomination of the Conservative party. But I do not believe I have lost the support of Conservatives. I still have a vision, I still have a strategy to fight for East Deschire, and I believe now is the time to rise to the challenge rather than back down and let partisan politics win.
"This won't be an easy campaign. It will be very difficult. I will have two opponents to focus on, and neither one of them is overly fond of me. But I will spend these next few months showing the people of East Deschire why they should send me back to Mavocke. And I intend to make my case to the voters."
Halitz's Independent bid will not be easy. Third party candidates have a mixed record of winning state-wide elections, although there have been recent exceptions.
Sen. Niles Gilcrest lost his primary race in 2010 to a more conservative opponent, but continued in the campaign as an Independent and won re-election in a three-way race.
Also in 2010, George Reedsworth, a moderate Conservative assemblyman from Trinton, lost his Senate primary race to a more socially conservative challenger, but went one to win the general election as an Independent.
Still, Sen. Michael Kreighorn (N-Biereland) lost his three-way race after losing the NAT nomination in 2010.
And in 2008, Carova Sen. Lee Schefsky (C) ran as an Independent but ultimately lost his bid for re-election.
Nonetheless, Halitz is optimistic about her chances.
"I think the voters will choose the best candidate, and I believe that candidate is me," she told a local radio DJ in Doylestown.
Nancy Lindselli also spoke with the media Thursday, saying she's "elated" her earlier recount victory was upheld in the hand recount.
"The voters have spoken. They chose me as the Conservative nominee, and I am honored to be nominated for the Grassadellian Federal Senate. I'm very pleased that both the machine recount and the hand recount came out in my favor. I'm somewhat disappointed that Denna Halitz has chosen to continue her campaign against the voters' wishes. She lost the election but is continuing on, and I'm disappointed that Denna didn't respect the will of the voters. But she has made her choice, and now we move on to the general election, and I look forward to the campaign. The wind is in the sails and we sail on full-steam ahead," said a confident Lindselli.
"The winds of change are in the air," she added.
Donna Rae Cobb (N), who is less known than her two conservative opponents and has so far stayed out of the CNS civil war, declined to comment on the intra-party battle between Halitz and Lindselli.
In a statement to the media, Cobb simply congratulated Lindselli on winning the CNS nomination, and congratulated Halitz on her Independent bid.
"I look forward to a very lively and spirited campaign," said Cobb.
Under East Deschire law, a candidate must receive 50% of the vote plus 1 to be declared the winner. If no candidate wins 50% plus 1 in the general election, a run-off election between the top two candidates will take place.
In order for the beleaguered Halitz to win, she will have to win more votes than Nancy Lindselli while also holding Donna Rae Cobb (N) under 50% of the vote. Then she will have to win a run-off election.
The same holds true for Lindselli, who must also win more votes than Denna Halitz and at the same time, keep Cobb from winning a majority of the votes, and then turn around and win a run-off election.
The election now strongly favors Cobb, as her two conservative opponents will likely split the conservative vote.
Though East Deschire is overall conservative-leaning, voters have elected several centrist Nationalists to state-wide office in recent years, including Gov. Lynn DeMont, Attorney General Rocky Morin, and Sens. Allison Sweeten and Portia McLendon.
Cobb, also a centrist, is hoping to position herself as a stable and likable alternative to her two conservative challengers.
Lindselli is hoping to ride an anti-Mavocke, anti-Menuhaeo, anti-NAT wave back to Mavocke.
Meanwhile, Lindselli will likely try to appeal to moderate Conservatives and Independents, and will continue to tout her accomplishments and her record as someone who "gets things done" for the Harvest State.
What's unclear is which, if either, of the candidates the CNS Senate Campaign Committee (CSCC) will back with support and fundraising.
Since Halitz lost the CNS nomination, it's doubtful she will retain the CSCC's support.
However, Lindselli defied Senate Minority Leader Jay Burns and other top CNS senators when she announced her primary challenge to Halitz.
Burns and other prominent party officials had privately and publicly asked Lindselli not to run against Halitz for the sake of party unity.
That decision may cost Lindselli the backing of the CSCC, which is expected to announce its general election strategy for East Deschire seat in the coming days.
East Deschire Secretary of State Jenny Sinderman today certified the results of the recount, which was conducted at the request of Halitz, after she lost an earlier machine recount to challenger Nancy Lindselli.
The final tally from the hand recount - which will be the official vote tally - has Lindselli winning with 50.44% or 186,991, and Halitz ending with 49.56% or 183,714.
Sinderman certified the results today, and reiterated her confidence in the outcome of the hand recount.
"I'm confident the final count from the hand recount is accurate," said Sinderman.
The hand recount was requested by Halitz, who initially was declared the winner a week after primary election day, drawing 50.5% to Nancy Lindselli's 49.5%.
After the original count, Lindselli, a former senator, requested and paid for a machine recount, which found her to be the winner, by a margin of 50.3% to 49.7%.
A desperate Halitz then requested - and also paid for - a more in-depth hand recount, which is considered a more accurate method of counting than a machine.
Last week, Lindselli was found to be the winner of the hand recount, having gained a small amount of votes.
Denna Halitz spent the last week considering her options - either concede and accept defeat, or launch an uphill Independent campaign for the Senate.
Today, the incumbent, who is seeking a second term, announced she will run as an Independent in the fall general election.
"Now is not the time for surrender. I have a vision for this state, for this country, and I intend to show the people of East Deschire over the next three months why they should send me back to the Senate, and why my opponent's partisanship and divisive ideological warfare is not right for East Deschire," said Halitz, referring to Lindselli's hard-hitting political style.
During her news conference, Halitz did not mention her NAT opponent, Assemblywoman Donna Rae Cobb (who represents the Hansboro-based seat of Forkwich), by name.
"East Deschireans deserve to have a choice in this election, and the choices couldn't be more clear. On the one side, we have a radical, bitter partisan, whose only goal is to go to Mavocke and give fiery speeches, trash-talk President Menuhaeo and oppose every bill from the Nationalists out of spite.
"On the other side, we have the exact opposite. We have someone who will rubber stamp everything President Menuhaeo and the Nationalists propose," said Halitz, referring to Cobb.
"And now I'm giving the voters a third choice. A proven conservative who loves East Deschire and will vote for what's right for East Deschire. I won't be an automatic 'no' vote and I won't be an automatic 'yes' vote. I won't obstruct the president, but I won't rubber stamp everything he wants either. I will vote for what's right for this state. I will oppose President Menuhaeo when he's wrong, and I'll back him up when he's right. But I won't demonize him and call him names and vote no just to be a thorn in his side. That's not the type behavior we need in a senator. We need someone who's compassionate, thoughtful, objective, professional, respectful to their colleagues, open-minded, and someone who's willing to partner with the other side if it means getting things done," said Halitz.
She continued: "I am here today to announce that I will continue my campaign for the Senate as an Independent. I accept the results of the multiple vote counts, and I accept that I have lost the nomination of the Conservative party. But I do not believe I have lost the support of Conservatives. I still have a vision, I still have a strategy to fight for East Deschire, and I believe now is the time to rise to the challenge rather than back down and let partisan politics win.
"This won't be an easy campaign. It will be very difficult. I will have two opponents to focus on, and neither one of them is overly fond of me. But I will spend these next few months showing the people of East Deschire why they should send me back to Mavocke. And I intend to make my case to the voters."
Halitz's Independent bid will not be easy. Third party candidates have a mixed record of winning state-wide elections, although there have been recent exceptions.
Sen. Niles Gilcrest lost his primary race in 2010 to a more conservative opponent, but continued in the campaign as an Independent and won re-election in a three-way race.
Also in 2010, George Reedsworth, a moderate Conservative assemblyman from Trinton, lost his Senate primary race to a more socially conservative challenger, but went one to win the general election as an Independent.
Still, Sen. Michael Kreighorn (N-Biereland) lost his three-way race after losing the NAT nomination in 2010.
And in 2008, Carova Sen. Lee Schefsky (C) ran as an Independent but ultimately lost his bid for re-election.
Nonetheless, Halitz is optimistic about her chances.
"I think the voters will choose the best candidate, and I believe that candidate is me," she told a local radio DJ in Doylestown.
Nancy Lindselli also spoke with the media Thursday, saying she's "elated" her earlier recount victory was upheld in the hand recount.
"The voters have spoken. They chose me as the Conservative nominee, and I am honored to be nominated for the Grassadellian Federal Senate. I'm very pleased that both the machine recount and the hand recount came out in my favor. I'm somewhat disappointed that Denna Halitz has chosen to continue her campaign against the voters' wishes. She lost the election but is continuing on, and I'm disappointed that Denna didn't respect the will of the voters. But she has made her choice, and now we move on to the general election, and I look forward to the campaign. The wind is in the sails and we sail on full-steam ahead," said a confident Lindselli.
"The winds of change are in the air," she added.
Donna Rae Cobb (N), who is less known than her two conservative opponents and has so far stayed out of the CNS civil war, declined to comment on the intra-party battle between Halitz and Lindselli.
In a statement to the media, Cobb simply congratulated Lindselli on winning the CNS nomination, and congratulated Halitz on her Independent bid.
"I look forward to a very lively and spirited campaign," said Cobb.
Under East Deschire law, a candidate must receive 50% of the vote plus 1 to be declared the winner. If no candidate wins 50% plus 1 in the general election, a run-off election between the top two candidates will take place.
In order for the beleaguered Halitz to win, she will have to win more votes than Nancy Lindselli while also holding Donna Rae Cobb (N) under 50% of the vote. Then she will have to win a run-off election.
The same holds true for Lindselli, who must also win more votes than Denna Halitz and at the same time, keep Cobb from winning a majority of the votes, and then turn around and win a run-off election.
The election now strongly favors Cobb, as her two conservative opponents will likely split the conservative vote.
Though East Deschire is overall conservative-leaning, voters have elected several centrist Nationalists to state-wide office in recent years, including Gov. Lynn DeMont, Attorney General Rocky Morin, and Sens. Allison Sweeten and Portia McLendon.
Cobb, also a centrist, is hoping to position herself as a stable and likable alternative to her two conservative challengers.
Lindselli is hoping to ride an anti-Mavocke, anti-Menuhaeo, anti-NAT wave back to Mavocke.
Meanwhile, Lindselli will likely try to appeal to moderate Conservatives and Independents, and will continue to tout her accomplishments and her record as someone who "gets things done" for the Harvest State.
What's unclear is which, if either, of the candidates the CNS Senate Campaign Committee (CSCC) will back with support and fundraising.
Since Halitz lost the CNS nomination, it's doubtful she will retain the CSCC's support.
However, Lindselli defied Senate Minority Leader Jay Burns and other top CNS senators when she announced her primary challenge to Halitz.
Burns and other prominent party officials had privately and publicly asked Lindselli not to run against Halitz for the sake of party unity.
That decision may cost Lindselli the backing of the CSCC, which is expected to announce its general election strategy for East Deschire seat in the coming days.