Conservative businesswoman Mary Shelley, from the northern suburbs of Marchande, won the party's nomination for Senate.
Her opponent was a far-right member of "The Proud Boys," an extremist right-wing group.
Cesar Canelo-Candide, 44, from the beach town of East Hampton on the north end of Cape Newton, had, at times, espoused violence, calling for a "conservative revolution."
His association with notorious members of The Proud Boys and other right-wing groups had earned him scorn from Nationalists and even from many fellow Conservatives.
There was some concern in Armana that Canelo-Candide might beat Shelley, who was hand-picked by the party establishment.
Polls had shown Shelley neck-and-neck with Canelo-Candide, and her lackluster fundraising numbers didn't reassure panicked supporters.
But ultimately, the little-known Shelley held off the bombastic Canelo-Candide by a wide margin, 60.6 - 39.4 percent, according to unofficial election results released by Armana Secretary of State Elaine Madaganan.
Voter turnout was just over 14 percent, Madaganan reported.
Support for the candidates didn't fall neatly into urban-versus-rural, with many rural counties backing Shelley, and some urban counties swinging in Canelo-Candide's favor.
Shelley won big in the Greater Marchande metro area, which put her so far ahead, there was no hope of Canelo-Candide overcoming the deficit. The race was called at about 10:00 pm, just two hours after the polls closed.
Despite having denied election results in previous elections, and casting suspicion on elections, particularly mail-in voting, Canelo-Candided did not contest the election results.
He issued a concession to Shelley around 10:30 pm, and the two reportedly spoke on the phone before Shelley gave an acceptance speech from her home in the northern suburbs of Marchande.
"Tonight, we have proven that you don't have to be the loudest, the most outspoken, the most hardcore candidate to win. We need to return the Senate to civility, and that begins with building relationships with other senators from other parties and by giving people the benefit of the doubt," said Shelley.
Canelo-Candide told his supporters gathered in his hometown on the cape that while he didn't win this race, "this is not the last of me."
"I'm not going nowhere," said Canelo-Candide, for whom English is a second language.
The 44-year-old was born in Venezuela, and had used his campaign to denounce communism.
He accused Shelley of being too soft on Nationalists, and not being conservative enough.
"When Nationalists are literally talking about socialism and buying property and taking over companies, we have to have a Conservative senator who will stand up to these lunatics and say 'hell no. Over my dead body.'"
Shelley also spoke out against communism, and disputed that her conservative credentials were in doubt.
"I'm a life-long Conservative. I'm from the party and movement of Edinough and Reagan. Everyone who knows me knows I don't support or tolerate communism or socialism, full stop," she said at a campaign event last week in Westernmyer.
Communism and socialism have become more prominent in international headlines, as left-wing politicians in multiple western countries have espoused the virtues of both socialism and, in lesser cases, communism.
And incumbent Sen. Serap Figaori (N), who is up for reelection and whom Shelley is challenging in December, has been accused of supporting socialism in the past.
Back in 2020, Figaori, then a freshman senator, supported the federal government nationalizing utility conglomerates.
"If we want to drive down the cost of electricity for Grassadellians, we can't keep letting the rotten, nasty electric companies continue to rob our citizens blind," he said in an interview back in 2020.
The senator also appeared alongside striking iron workers in northern Armana, demanding higher pay and better benefits from employers.
His staunch pro-labor and pro-social democratic policies have given Conservatives much fodder, as they seek to defeat him in his quest for a third term in the Senate.
However, most polling has shown Figaori -- despite his left-wing views -- comfortably ahead in his bid for reelection.
With Shelley, a first-time candidate, having little name recognition, Conservatives will have to pour in millions of dollars just to raise awareness of Shelley. Polls have shown most voters don't know anything about her.
As of last week, Shelley's campaign reported it had raised $6.47 million, and had about $3.9 million in cash-on-hand.
Figaori's campaign reported the senator had raised $6.69 million, and had $4.2 million on hand.
In his previous campaigns, Figaori has been an adept fundraiser, with more than half of his campaign donations coming from outside the state.
***Conservative Senate Primary Election -- Armana -- Unofficial Results***
| 828,953 | 538,681 |
| 60.61% | 39.39% |
| Shelley | Canelo-Candide |